Standing desks may not be that helpful, study finds

Sitting down is killing you, in more than one way. Study after study has shown how bad sitting down is, and yet the vast majority of the developed world still spends most of their time sitting down. As a result, a new trend was picking up – standing desks. It seems to make a lot of sense, but a new study casts the benefits of standing desks into doubt.

“What we actually found is that most of it is, very much, just fashionable and not proven good for your health,” says Dr. Jos Verbeek, a health researcher at the Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, who conducted the study.

Photo by ramsey everydaypants.

Standing desks became fashionable fast. Even we tried them at one of our offices, though to little avail (we simply didn’t like it, to be honest). But the science has yet to back them up. The quality of evidence was very low to low, with poorly designed studies and very few participants – that’s just one of the conclusions of a paper, published last week in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.

“At present there is very low to low quality evidence that sit-stand desks may decrease workplace sitting between thirty minutes to two hours per day without having adverse effects at the short or medium term. There is no evidence on the effects in the long term,” the study reads.

They found that on average, sit-stand desks alone decreased workplace sitting with about half an hour to two hours per day. However, this didn’t seem to have any noticeable effect on mortality rate and overall health. Instead, they found that other, more conventional methods like going for a jog are far more effective. This isn’t to say that standing desks don’t help, just that at the moment, there is no scientific information to back that up.

“There is a need for cluster-randomised trials with a sufficient sample size and long term follow-up to determine the effectiveness of different types of interventions to reduce objectively measured sitting time at work,” the researchers write.

The findings are consistent with another review published last year. Then, researchers concluded that both standing desks and treadmills may offer health benefits, but there is simply not enough good science on the topic – although both methods somewhat reduce productivity.

“However, at present there still exist substantial gaps in the research to fully comprehend the utility of each type of desk to promote health. Therefore additional research is necessary in order to determine the appropriateness of these desks with respect to enhancing health benefits by reducing sedentary time.”

In the meantime, you’d be much better off stretching every half an hour and talking a walk every couple of hours.

5 thoughts on “Standing desks may not be that helpful, study finds

  1. puzzlelady

    I used a stand-up counter for years and found it more efficient for reaching objects on the work surface and sparing my knees from the strain of getting up and sitting down a hundred times a day. I had greater freedom of movement and quicker response times while standing up. Later, having a laptop sent me to a sitting position but with my feet up to keep them from swelling. Still looking to design an ideal desk for both body position and mobility. A furniture designer who comes up with the ideal combination will not only win users’ gratitude but make millions of bucks.

  2. Al Junio R

    My Uncle spent all his working life standing behind a butcher’s counter…had leg veins like a roadmap of Europe..not good.
    The stool isn’t too bad as an addition at work stations, but getting managers to follow factory law (can’t make you stand if you can do your job equally well sitting), or to treat floor workers as equal to their own sit down jobs, is nearly impossible at some places.

  3. Pingback: Picking The Right Standing Desk For Your Workplace – The Blogging of Boesen 266

  4. Pingback: Standing Desk – What Is The Health Advantages? – The Life of Buch 972

  5. Pingback: Standing Desk – Wonderful For Your Workplace – The Journaling of Ritchie 875

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *