Myth bashing: Bears are not ferocious flesh-eaters

Bears are among the largest mammals and rule the top of the food chain in forests around the world. Many people are scared to encounter a bear when they are hiking or camping in the woods. Grizzly bears attacks are sensationalized, but only happen extremely rarely. For example, out of 104 million visitors to Yellowstone national park from 1980-2015, 38 were injured by grizzly bears. There is a common perception that they are true carnivores and stalk through the forest hunting for deer and other large prey as their main food. Although bears are often classified as carnivores, their diet is actually mostly composed of plants. Not so exciting, right? When they do eat meat, it’s usually already dead or a very small mammal like a rabbit or mouse.

Actually, this brown bear is just yawning. Image credits: Rob Hurson

At least 85% of a bear’s diet is made up of plants. So they are not really carnivores, and even barely omnivores. Black bears (Ursus americanus) in North America and brown bears (Ursus arctos) in North America and Eurasia are the most common bears worldwide. In the spring when emerging from torpor, the bears dig for roots and eat new plant shoots. For protein, they scavenge for dead deer that didn’t survive the winter and they may kill fawns. For protein supplements they eat insects; they target mostly social insects because there are large amounts of them in one place. In the summer, the bears mostly eat berries and fruit because they provide a lot of energy. In the fall, bears eat many kilograms of nuts, roots, and bulbs a day to bulk up for the winter.

However, the diets of bears vary depending on their region. In warmer areas of Eurasia even more than 90% of their diet could be plant-based. In drier areas, such as the sub-arctic, bears may eat substantially more meat (up to half of their diet). There’s a lack of plant species so bears eat more deer or caribou to make up for that. Usually, most of the mammals that they consume are under 10 kg (22 pounds), like rabbits and mice. Occasionally bears have been known to hunt adult deer. Even rarer are cases of bears ambushing adult moose. In the Pacific coast area, bears fish for salmon, and can catch other fish. Bears are only dangerous to humans when an unnatural relationship is established between them, such as when humans feed bears. This behaviour causes bears to lose their fear of humans and not be afraid to approach.

You can’t fake that kind of excitement. Image credits: Abu0804

The other bear species around the world

Asiatic black bears (Selenarctos thibetanus)

Found in: Iran to south-east Asia

Diet: Asiatic black bears eat mostly grasses, fruit, berries, seeds, honey, and nuts. For protein they munch on small vertebrates, insects, and carrion.

Asiatic black bears. Image credits: Drew Avery

Giant panda (Ailuropoda melanoluca)

Found in: fragmented mountain ranges in Western China

Diet: Pandas have a diet that is comprised of 99% bamboo, of which they eat 12-38 kg a day to meet their energy needs. On rare occasions, they eat other plants and small rodents or pikas.

Talk about a favourite food… Image credits: skeeze

Andean bears (Tremarctos ornatus)

Found in: the Andes in South America

Diet: Andean bears are similar to pandas in that their diet is 95% plant-based. They mostly eat fruit, bromeliads, palms, and cacti. They also indulge on insects and rodents.

The Andean bear is also called the spectacled bear because of its facial markings. Image credits: Paul Hudson

Sloth bears (Melursus ursinus)

Found in: India, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh

Diet: Sloth bears eat mostly ants, termites, and fruit. They eat more fruit during the growing season and a majority of insects during the rest of the year.

The sloth bear is found mostly in India. Image credits: JudaM

Sun bear (Helarctos malayanus)

Found in: Southeast Asia

Diet: Sun bears eat almost anything that they can find in the rainforest. This includes bees, honey, insects, fruit, birds, eggs, reptiles, deer, and small mammals.

How ferocious! Image credits: 3342

Polar bear (Ursus maritimus)

Found in: the whole Arctic

Diet: The only exception! Because there are very few plants growing in the Arctic, polar bears rely almost exclusively on seal fat for food. Some food alternatives are reindeer, rodents, kelp, birds, and berries.

The only real carnivore is the polar bear. Image credits: AWeith

Most bears don’t actively hunt very much and follow a mostly plant-based diet. Only bears that live in areas without much vegetation, like the arctic or sub-arctic, hunt for more meat. These bears don’t have much contact with humans because these areas are scarcely populated. The chances of being attacked by a bear are low, but it is still important to take necessary precautions in areas known to have bears.

4 thoughts on “Myth bashing: Bears are not ferocious flesh-eaters

  1. Michael Fearon

    This bear – report was interesting, yet possibly, too optomistic.
    Please be sure to read about humans killed by black bears in Algonquin Park, Ontario, Canada.

  2. bonnie

    Bears are not vegetarians. They opportunistic omnivores. They will eat just about anything that smells like food to them. Indiscriminately. With minimum of effort.

  3. Brian

    I notice you only mention brown bears in passing. Brown bears are the most dangerous to humans.

    "In a study of more recent black bears attacks, both lethal and nonlethal, Herrero and Hank Hristienko, a biologist with the Manitoba provincial government, found 92 attacks across Canada and the U.S. from 2010 to 2013. The number of attacks annually climbed from 19 in 2010 to 32 last year."

    Yet some folks are still claiming 1 or two per year. I would take bear mace with you if you live in an area with a lot of bears. Know what types of bears are around and how to deal with them.

  4. Pingback: Black Bears are not scary after all. – Imagine Our Florida, Inc

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *